What conflicts does MAS highlight?
Appendix 5 gives examples of potential conflicts and mitigating practices. The following is a brief summary, rather than an exhaustive checklist.
| Scenario | Main concern |
|---|---|
| Additional or unusual fees | Investors bear charges without adequate disclosure. |
| Buying services from connected businesses | Personal interests influence supplier selection or pricing. |
| Manager or connected persons co-investing | Preferential terms disadvantage fund investors. |
| Funds with overlapping strategies | Unfair allocations or one fund supporting another. |
| Investing in connected portfolio companies | Decisions favour insiders over investors or depart from the mandate. |
| Extending a fund or moving investors into another fund | Fees or business interests drive the proposal. |
| Conflicts committees lacking independence or expertise | Approvals do not adequately represent investors’ interests. |
Source: MAS guidelines, Appendix 5, pages 26–29.
The examples below focus on outside interests, connected investments and staff participation, followed by the records and checks I would expect to see.
Start with what management has declared
When I review conflicts arrangements, I want to see whether management has given compliance enough information to assess the situation.
A director might hold an advisory role in a pharmaceutical company, own shares in another business and sit on several boards. Each connection needs enough detail for the firm to understand whether it could affect investment decisions or other responsibilities.
Management needs to disclose changes promptly through the firm’s procedures. Compliance cannot reasonably be expected to independently uncover every interest that someone deliberately conceals. It can assess declarations, challenge inconsistencies and follow up on warning signs within its remit.
An omission can become much harder to explain when an investor later discovers that their money went into a company connected to senior management. Poor investment performance does not itself establish misconduct, but the undisclosed connection raises a separate governance question.
Assess a connected investment before committing
Consider a hypothetical VCFM whose CEO holds shares in a company that the fund is considering investing in. I would want the connection flagged before the investment proceeds, with the proposal checked against the fund’s mandate and the firm’s conflicts policy.
MAS’s Appendix 5 discusses investments in portfolio companies owned or controlled by the manager or connected persons. Its examples emphasise investors’ best interests, consistency with the investment mandate, objective justification, appropriate disclosure and sufficient independence in approving committees. These situations are not subject to a blanket prohibition in that guidance. MAS guidelines, Appendix 5.
A firm may choose stricter internal restrictions. Where its policy permits consideration of a connected investment, I would expect a related-party transaction assessment to explain the connection, investment rationale, terms, risks and proposed safeguards before approval.
Make the approval process meaningful
The firm’s governing documents and committee rules determine the approval route. A majority vote deserves closer scrutiny when several people voting are connected to the transaction.
I would want the records to show who challenged the proposal, what questions they asked and how those questions were resolved. A Non-Executive Director may provide that challenge, but their independence from the particular transaction needs consideration too.
The assessment should capture any abstentions, objections, conditions and required investor or committee disclosures. Compliance can coordinate the review and document its advice, while the authorised decision-makers remain responsible for their decision.
MAS also states that CEOs and Executive Directors may need to divest outside business interests where conflicts or reputational risks cannot be adequately mitigated. MAS guidelines, paragraph 3.9.
Check how staff and directors invest alongside clients
My starting position is that employees and directors should not use their position to obtain earlier redemptions or better allocations at other investors’ expense.
Before agreeing to a staff fee concession, check the fund documents, the approval arrangements, the disclosures and whether the concession shifts costs onto other investors. Employee eligibility to invest also needs its own assessment.
Investment in the managed fund and personal co-investment in a portfolio company should be assessed separately. The arrangements create different questions about terms, allocations and who benefits.
Keep the declarations, decisions and email threads
Recordkeeping is one of the most important parts of the review. Keep the declarations, assessments, checks, reports, approvals and relevant email correspondence together so someone can follow what happened.
If the firm commits to quarterly declarations, there should be dated written responses showing what each person declared or confirmed for that period. Quarterly declarations are an example of a firm’s chosen procedure, rather than a universal frequency.
Where a change requires notification to MAS, retain the submitted notification and acknowledgement. An internal declaration and a regulatory notification are separate steps, each with its own purpose.
If a record is missing, establish what happened and document the gap honestly. Reconstructing events should preserve the distinction between contemporaneous evidence and a later explanation.
Test the controls promised in the policy
I would then select a sample and test whether the firm followed its own procedures.
For a connected investment, trace the declared interest through the compliance assessment, approval, conditions and relevant disclosures. Check whether these steps happened at the required stage and whether any follow-up remained outstanding.
For quarterly declarations, check whether the responses were obtained, reviewed and followed up. An unanswered reminder is still an outstanding item.
Record the sample, evidence reviewed, findings, responsible person and follow-up date. This gives management something concrete to act on and supports the wider fund management compliance monitoring programme.
A workable conflicts framework should let the firm explain the connection, justify its decision and demonstrate that the safeguards were followed. Those are the records I would want to see.
For help reviewing your arrangements, explore Advisors Assemble’s fund manager compliance support or venture capital fund manager compliance support.